Every year, railroads in the United States remove and replace more than 20 million creosote-treated wooden crossties which have reached the end of their useful service life. This remarkable figure actually represents only four percent of the 560 to 590 million creosote-treated ties installed across the United States, thanks to treated crossties’ popularity and long service life.
Given creosote-treated crossties’ ubiquity across the country, policymakers and industry leaders continually analyze their impact on the environment and evaluate their effectiveness against alternatives which may compete with the approximately 150-year-old technology. Every 15 years the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) formally reviews creosote under its Registration Review Program, and has continuously approved its use for more than 75 years. In 2023 the Federal Railroad Administration sought policy guidance regarding the best ways to reuse, recycle or dispose of America’s creosote-treated crossties at the end of their service lives (1) and in 2025 the EPA also implemented new protocols to increase safety and cleanliness at treatment plants (2).
To properly evaluate the environmental impact of creosote treatment, a life-cycle assessment (LCA) must be performed. An LCA takes into account the costs and impacts associated with the full life cycle of a product, from raw material extraction through manufacture and disposal, rather than just at one point in time. Central to these efforts to minimize environmental harm is whether toxins are released into the environment during installation, service life, and upon removal. How and how many toxins in the creosote pressure-impregnated wood cells migrate outside of the wood and into the natural environment is critical to measuring treated crossties’ impact on the environment and predicting any potential impacts of the disposal process.
Two studies provide insight into whether the organic carbon-based chemicals derived from coal in creosote negatively impact the natural environment: a 2004 field study by the USDA Forest Products Laboratory and a 2005 laboratory experiment by Kang et al. Both found that in moist conditions the creosote in new crossties as well as weathered crossties is greatly limited in its ability to migrate to the broader environment.
Two studies provide insight into whether the organic carbon-based chemicals derived from coal in creosote negatively impact the natural environment: a 2004 field study by the USDA Forest Products Laboratory and a 2005 laboratory experiment by Kang et al. Both found that in moist conditions—which pose the highest risk of migration due to water’s solvent capabilities—the creosote in new crossties as well as weathered crossties is greatly limited in its ability to migrate to the broader environment.

USDA Forest Products Laboratory Study
The USDA field study (“Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon (PAH) Migration from Creosote-Treated Railway Ties into Ballast and Adjacent Wetlands”) analyzed the environmental safety of creosote-treated ties at the beginning of their lifecycle. The study was motivated by concerns over replacement of railroad ties in environmentally sensitive wetlands inhabited by the endangered Hines emerald dragonfly.
The 18-month study documented the migration of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Researchers constructed three identical wetland “mesocosms” (controlled outdoor ecosystems):
- Newly creosote-treated railroad ties
- Weathered (used) creosote-treated ties
- Untreated hardwood ties (control)
PAHs were monitored in ballast, wetland sediments, groundwater, surface stormwater, and soil cores (3). Over the 18-month period of sampling, researchers found that a minimal amount of PAHs migrated only into the crushed stone ballast directly surrounding the treated wood, and only for one season. Importantly, the release did not bring PAH levels higher than typical background levels and did not accumulate with time.
Over the 18-month period of sampling, researchers found that a minimal amount of PAHs migrated only into the crushed stone ballast directly surrounding the treated wood, and only for one season. Importantly, the release did not bring PAH levels higher than typical background levels and did not accumulate with time.
Kang et al. Study: Creosote Movement from Treated Wood Immersed in Fresh Water
The laboratory study by Kang et al., published in the Forest Products Journal in 2005, came to the same conclusions by studying creosote-treated wood in a simulated lab environment. From the outset, the study acknowledges creosote’s longstanding value: “Creosote has been widely used to protect railroad ties, utility poles, bridge timbers, and piling against fungal, insect, and marine borer attack since its introduction in the 1830s. Creosote is a distillate of coal tar, a byproduct of the carbonization of coal” (4).
The researchers sought to identify the dynamics behind PAHs’ migration from treated wood, because creosote has a “long history of successful use as a wood preservative, but polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in this preservative have raised environmental concerns, particularly when creosote-treated wood is used in aquatic environments.” Kang et al. complemented the USDA research by providing more granular detail regarding how exposure of treated wood to varying flow rates of water influences the migration of PAHs.
The authors established the migration behavior of creosote-treated wood when submerged in fresh flowing water by measuring the concentrations of seven PAHs (out of the 16 PAHs considered hazardous pollutants) at different points in time. They compared different flow rates as well as different wood treatment scenarios, from freshly treated railroad ties to weathered ties. This data will be used to develop models that can predict the movement of creosote from treated wood into aquatic environments.
Freshly treated wood released only lighter-weight PAHs when first exposed to flowing water—after just one week, this reduced to miniscule amounts. Heavier PAHs remain in the wood due to their low water solubility. Therefore, crossties older than one year, including used crossties up for disposal, do not appear to significantly transfer PAHs to the environment.
Similar to the field conditions studied by the USDA, freshly treated wood released only lighter-weight PAHs when first exposed to flowing water—after just one week, this reduced to miniscule amounts. Heavier PAHs remain in the wood due to their low water solubility. Therefore, crossties older than one year, including used crossties up for disposal, do not appear to significantly transfer PAHs to the environment.

Two Studies, One Conclusion: Creosote-Treated Wood Appears to have Minimal Impact on the Surrounding Environment
Kang et al. investigated the fundamental migration behavior of freshly creosote-treated wood specimens, providing a mechanistic explanation for why the USDA Forest Products Laboratory observed in the field only a brief period of elevated PAH release from creosote-treated railroad ties. Together, these two studies support a joint conclusion: new creosote-treated railroad ties exhibit a brief period of elevated PAH release immediately after installation, which is typically observed in the first summer season, but migration of PAHs is greatly diminished into aquatic environments after one year as well as over the long-term.
While more work is still needed to better define the dynamics, e.g. water temperature, pH, and flow dynamics that can possibly influence the migration from creosote-treated crossties, this work supports the conclusion that PAHs migrate only minimally from creosote-treated wood.
The Creosote Council and its members maintain a product stewardship approach to help ensure the safe use of creosote-treated wood in the environment through Best Management Practices and the support through research and sound science to keep our environment healthy for today and into the future.
This article was originally published in the Railway Tie Association’s Crossties Magazine.
Notes
- Request for Information Regarding Uses for Used Creosote-Treated Railroad Ties, https://railroads.dot.gov/regulations/federal-register-documents/2023-08689
- Creosote Council, “EPA Approves Updated Creosote Labeling,” March 4, 2025. https://creosotecouncil.org/blog/epa-approves-updated-creosote-labeling/
- Brooks, Kenneth M. United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service. Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon Migration from Creosote-Treated Railway Ties Into Ballast and Adjacent Wetlands. https://research.fs.usda.gov/treesearch/7043
- Kang, Sung-Mo; Morrell, Jeffrey J.; Simonsen, John; Lebow, Stan. Forest Products Journal. “Creosote movement from treated wood immersed in fresh water,” 2005. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/237442654_Creosote_movement_from_treated_wood_immersed_in_fresh_water